Which Supernatural Guy Would Fall For You?

1.7K Shares

Things are getting steamy in the fight against the forces of evil. Can you catch the eye of one of these evil-fighting SOBs? Watch out, the demons are on the prowl as well. Can you get the attention of Sam, Dean, or Castiel before one of the bad guys takes notice? Wander, lost in the world of Supernatural using your arcane knowledge from the show. Answer the questions right and you will impress one of the good guys. Answer wrong and you may strike a cord with one of the evil forces in this terrifying world.

Can you survive the mysterious world of angels and demons, and capture the attention of your Supernatural crush? Find out which character from Supernatural may have a crush on you. What would you do if you were wrapped up in the Supernatural world? Who would you save if you could only save one? Who would you want fighting beside you? It's a Supernatural choose your own adventure with five different endings.

Are you ready to play? Scroll down or click the button to get ready and launch into the quiz. You never know who you might end up with until you try. Get ready, set, go!

Question 1

Choose your weapon.

choose your weapon game controllers

What do you bring with you to investigate a supernatural incident? Each of these items has its use against the undead. Each one has gotten Sam and Dean out of countless scrapes. It's a good thing super powerful monsters have such obvious weak points. Which of these would you not want to hunt the supernatural without?

Question 2

Where are you headed?

angel or devil

Which place has your name on it? Have you had a room in Heaven reserved ever since you were a little child? Did you cancel that reservation for something a little more spicy? Do you reject the idea of ever giving up and going anywhere? Pick the place where you would probably land in the Supernatural universe.

Question 3

Pop quiz: How do you banish a ghost?

Sam fighting ghosts in Supernatural

Some of our Supernatural friends are only interested in people who are equally knowledgeable in the occult, people who can hold their own against the arcane. Do you know how to handle yourself against a ghost? Answer this question correctly and you may capture the attention of a certain someone.

Question 4

Pick a pet.

choose a pet

Which animal would you like to take home today? Animals are like their owners. Sometimes people and their pets have such similar personalities that it's almost baffling. The animal you choose may very well be the pet that your beau from Supernatural would pick as well, if he wasn't so busy fighting arcane forces.

Question 5

Choose a power.

Rowena the witch

Time to pick a power! Some take years upon years to master, and the learning curve is steep. The powers of a witch are limitless with the right tools and training. Demonic power is more straight-forward, more brute force than anything else, but the effects wear on the soul and turn the host into something horrific, at least on a moral level.

Question 6

You found a wallet. What do you do?

cat wallet

Everyone has limits, some with good reason. Certain limits are a matter of conscience. What are you willing to do if you run across a wallet? Would you actually do this in real life, or would you end up doing something else entirely? What do you choose to do with the wallet?

Question 7

Pick a career.

It's Career Day but no one is becoming a pharmacist or event planner. The choices are a little different this time, and a lot more dangerous. Knowing what is really out there, do you follow the footsteps of Sam and Dean or do you go down a more devious route?

Question 8

Pop quiz: Which repels demons?

lucifer laugh supernatural

Certain members of the supernatural may not wish for you to know how to take them down, demons specifically. Answer this incorrectly and a certain evil one will feel more at ease around you. That is unless his ego is too big to be concerned about little things like mortals trying to take him down.

Question 9

Would you make a deal with Crowley?

Crowley supernatural

This man always keeps his deals. It is what allowed him to climb to the top of the demonic food chain after Lucifer was taken out of the picture. Sam and Dean have made countless deals with this sly fellow and their heads are still intact. Do you believe you are crafty enough to make a deal with this fellow?

Question 10

Time for a snack.

pick a snack

You're feeling pretty peckish and it's time to fill up. There is no sense in going into a fight with an empty stomach. Which of these fine foods do you fill up your stomach with before braving the line between dead and alive? If hunting isn't really your thing, which would you eat before a long session of watching TV?

Question 11

Choose a Hogwarts house.

Let's take a side trip to Hogwarts. Which house do you have your eyes set on? Which house are you sure will be the one to take you in just as soon as your acceptance letter finds its way over to you? Some acceptance letters are getting lost in the mail.

Question 12

How far would you go to save a friend?

sam and dean in lucifer's cage

Sam and Dean are prepared to do anything to protect each other, even if it means risking the whole world around them. They are simply not prepared to continue the fight against evil without each other. Our demon friends are another story, and back-stabbing isn't unheard of even amongst supposed allies.

Question 13

What is your guilty pleasure?

What do you spend your time on when there is no one around to judge you? What do you only talk about with certain friends because you know they will give you Hell for it if they think it's funny? If none of these things are your guilty pleasure, which do you enjoy the most?

Question 14

Choose an accessory.

supernatural accessories

Time to accessorize. Which little accessory will catch the eye of your Supernatural Prince Charming? If these are oddly specific, it is because we are up against some oddly specific people. Each of these is bound to capture the attention of a certain someone, possibly a dangerous someone. Which do you pick?

Question 15

What's your best quality?

Sam and bleeding mirror in Supernatural

What is the greatest, most unique thing about you? Is it a facet of your brain or your body? Is it something you have honed over the years or something you were born with? What is it about you that makes you special, important, or the most successful in life?

Question 16

Select a rival.

I'm Gary motherfucking Oak

Which character from Supernatural do you choose to be your rival? This is the person who you compete with, and whose daggers you are constantly dodging. You may also be throwing a few daggers for yourself. Your rival may be someone you are jealous of, someone who has something you want, or someone who challenges you to work your hardest.

Question 17

You can only save one.

Sam and Dean hug

The hell hounds are closing in. The angels are swarming from the sky. A powerful spell is sweeping the area and you only have the chance to protect one of these from the inferno. Maybe, just maybe, the others will find a way to scrape by, but it's looking dire. If you can only protect one of these, which do you pick?

Question 18

Pop quiz: Which of these can defeat an angel?

Castiel Supernatural wings

Angels are the good guys, right? Well, unfortunately, this is not always true. Angels have their own idea of what the world should be like, especially without a higher power to guide their actions. One or thousands of them may even get in your way. A certain someone would feel much better if you could handle yourself against angels.

Question 19

What is your alignment?

alignment beards

Get out your character sheet, it's time to figure out how good or evil you really are, and how important law and order is to you at the same time. These four options sit in the corners of the most famous D&D morality grid. Choose carefully because you never know whose attention you will catch.

Question 20

Pick a quote.

Sam and Dean silly faces

Has one of the Supernatural characters ever made you laugh out loud? Most of the show is all about taking down supernatural mysteries, extremely powerful beings that two ordinary hunters have no business messing with. The little moments of humor catch everyone off guard, but that is one of the things that makes them so fantastic.

Question 21

Would you let Castiel possess you?

Castiel human host

It's for the greater good and you know it, but can you actually go through with it? Being possessed does not seem like an enjoyable experience, but Castiel's hands are tied without, well, hands. Will you be the arms and legs of this powerful angel and do your part to save the world?

Question 22

Pick a screenshot.

Sam and Dean funny screenshots

Select a screenshot from Supernatural that makes you smile. These two moments are the stuff of legend, the things that drive Supernatural fans back to the show again and again. It's not the serious times, it's the silly ones. Do you remember these moments? Pick the screenshot that speaks to you the most, for any reason.

Question 23

What do you do for fun?

sam drinking supernatural

Everyone has hobbies, even hunters and their supernatural prey. What do you do to keep your mind off the stresses of life and enjoy yourself for a while? What do you look forward to after a long day at work, even if your work isn't as exciting as hunting demons?

Question 24

Pop quiz: What do angels need to possess you?

Lucifer the rock star spreads his wings in Supernatural

One of the perks of being a demon is that they can do whatever they like whenever they like. Even without a higher power looking over their shoulder, there are still rules that angels must follow. There are still certain things that angels simply cannot do, even if demons have no problem with it.

Question 25

Pick a fighting partner.

Supernatural Castiel fight

Who would you want on your side in a fight to the death against dangerous entities? Many are good with a gun, and many have the knowledge necessary to navigate the supernatural world. Some very rare allies possess magical prowess. Who do you want at your side in a dangerous fight?

See Your Result
Questions Left