Was It Friends Or How I Met Your Mother? Only Real Fans Will Pass This Quiz

Whether we are watching them sip coffees at Central Perk, or watching them cheers each other at MacLaren's pub - we love hanging out with these two unforgettable groups of friends. They have both managed to make us all laugh, cry, and sing along during their 9 and 10 year runs on television.

While we have been kicking it with Rachel, Phoebe, Chandler, Joey, Monica, and Ross a little bit longer due to their first season airing on September of 1994 - that is not to say we haven't equally enjoyed our time in New York City with our other band of misfits. Marshall, Ted, Barney, Lily, and Robin only first got the chance to crack us up in September 2005 and we've been in love ever since.

Both of these award-winning television shows have definitely earned their own spot on the list of legendary sitcoms. With such similar premises though, we can't help but look back and wonder sometimes, "Was it Joey or Ted who said that?" or, "Was it Lily or Phoebe who sang that song?" Today we test just how closely you were paying attention to the finer details of both these shows. Think you are up for the challenge? Let's find out!

Question 1

"We were on a break!" Which show do these famous words come from?

We first hear these words in the 15th episode of season 3 and continue to hear it throughout the rest of the series. The phrase is initially used to justify an affair that may or may not have taken place before the couple in question actually splits. By the end of this series it is no surprise that all characters not involved in the cheating scandal cringe as soon as they hear these words yelled. Can you remember which unfaithful character said this, and the show they belong to?

Question 2

In which show do the characters enjoy throwing interventions for each other?

An intervention is a safe place where friends and family can approach you and discuss an issue they see impacting your life and/or theirs. Usually taken quite seriously and used to ultimately help the parties involved, this show instead uses interventions as a way to change every little thing they don't like about you. Whether it be an article of clothing you've over-worn or a relationship you should have long ago ended, this group of friends will sit you down and let you know about it.

Question 3

In which show are a duck and chick kept as pets?

TV has given us so many memorable animal/human relationships. We tend to fall for these on-screen fuzzy friends just like we would our own. We become attached and generally care about their well being. In this unique situation it isn't a fluffy puppy , or a cute baby kitten that play with our heart strings, but instead a lovable duck and an adorable baby chick. In which New York City apartment do these tiny animals live their best city lives?

Question 4

Which show does this secondary character belong to?

This pale-haired, socially awkward fella is part of this sitcoms entire series. While never a main character he does get his own small story lines which always hilariously involve his obsession over one of our leading ladies. His spot-on portrayal of Charlie Brown during one of the show's Halloween episodes definitely earns him his spot in this quiz. Fun fact: This character's notable voice also happens to be used in all of the show's special features on the DVD box-set.

Question 5

In which show do we witness a character get beaten-up by a goat?

There are plenty of fight scenes between both shows; some physical, some emotional, all devastating in their own right. In one of the shows in particularly we see a few downright dirty fights take place. Normally the scenes are involving human on human altercations, however, there is one instance where they change it up. In this scene we witness a main character go head to head in a fight against a goat. Can you remember in which show we see our brave character get taken down by this animal?

Question 6

In which show do we see a blue french horn hanging in a character's apartment?

While the blue french horn does spend most of the series run hanging on a main character's apartment wall, that is not where we first see it appear. The musical instrument becomes an epic sign of 2 character's undeniable love for each other. Seeing it on the wall of the apartment is always a friendly reminder of their relationship even when they are both with other people. Can you recall which love story is based in this french horn and what show it belongs to?

Question 7

"The Mermaid Theory" comes from which show?

The Mermaid Theory is essentially the belief that after spending an undetermined amount of time with someone you are not attracted to, you will eventually change and become attracted to them. While the mermaid theory is not an exact science, it does become relevant in an episode of the show in question, after 2 main characters who normally did not spend time 1 on 1 together, get thrown into a scenario in which they see each other in a different light.

Question 8

During a flash back in which show do we see a character get stuck in a bean bag chair?

Who doesn't love a good flash back episode? Entire shows like Family Guy have been based completely on flash backs and our love for them. As we grow more and more attached to our favorite characters it is only normal that we become excited at the prospect of getting a glimpse into their past lives. Can you remember which show flashes us back to the hilarious moment when a leading lady takes a seat in a bean bag chair, and is unable to get back up?

Question 9

"MY SANDWICH!?" In which show do these words get yelled?

There's nothing quite like the excitement of knowing there is a delicious lunch packed, and waiting for you in the fridge. Imagine thinking about it all day to only then realize when opening the fridge that someone has taken it! Unacceptable to say the least... The character in question faces this exact situation, and reasonably becomes furious once finding out someone in his office has eaten his leftover turkey sandwich. In which show do we hear the irate outburst of "MY SANDWICH?"

Question 10

In which show does Bruce Willis claim to be a "cool guy"?

This may not be the role Bruce Willis is most famous for but it is certainly one of his funniest. Bruce plays the father of a young girl dating one of our leading men. In his 3 episode stretch on the show his character ends up dating one of our leading ladies himself. This relationship fails due to his inability to stop crying. Fun fact: Bruce played this role for free after losing a bet to one of the main characters in real life!

Question 11

In which show does a character get a turkey stuck on their head?

As unlikely as it seems during the Thanksgiving episode of the show's 5th season, 2 characters actually end up with turkeys on their heads. While one is trying to pull a prank and hilariously gets the turkey stuck on his head, the other uses the turkey as a sort of apology. The turkey-head apology actually ends up leading into one of the series' most unforgettably romantic scenes. Can you remember which of these shows features these two bird wearing jokers?

Question 12

In which show does a leading man love motivational posters?

We see them in offices, waiting rooms, sometimes in annoyingly optimistic people's homes. Motivational posters are probably the least motivating thing to have hanging on a wall. This character goes above and beyond by having every inch of their office covered in them. While he keeps some of the classics, he also enjoys the hobby of creating some himself. Normally resulting in an overly-offensive or nonsensical adaptation of a motivation poster. In which show do we see this character's creations hanging on his office wall?

Question 13

In which show does a leading lady get offered her dream job in Japan?

While it's never easy saying good-bye, it may be even harder watching your favorite TV characters say it to one another. Let's face it the friendships developed for television are hand crafted to ensure they appeal to the largest group of us possible. They are written for us. So after investing our time watching them on screen we grow emotionally attached, this already makes saying goodbye to them hard but then we also have to watch their heart breaking good-byes to each other! UGH!

Question 14

Which show advises us that nothing ever good happens after 2 A.M?

Probably some of the best advice given on a sitcom ever. We first learn this lesson in the 18th episode of the first season. Throughout the episode we see one character's determination to prove this statement wrong, while the others are convinced of the opposite. One of our leading men decides to push his luck by staying out too late and inevitably ruining more than one relationship, and ultimately realizing the truth behind the quote: "Nothing good happens after 2 a.m".

Question 15

In which show does a leading lady fall asleep and have a mustache drawn on her face?

Everyone loves it when a group of TV show characters pack up their bags and head off on a trip away from the regular sites and views of the city we are used to seeing them in. This incident is no different. It takes place during a 2 part episode where the gang jets off to Vegas. Before even arriving at their destination a prank war ensues between these 2 characters on their flight. Can you remember who wakes up to the unhappy surprise of a mustache drawn on their face in permanent marker?

Question 16

"Cat funeral" Which show does this song belong to?

"Cat funeral, cat funeral, it was an accident. And not entirely my fault. Cat funeral, cat funeral (I miss you whiskers)." This heart breaker of a song goes along with a main character's addiction to making online videos, making it a very funny scene to watch, but also highlighting the sad fact that Whiskers the cat has passed away while in his care. While we all take a moment to remember Whiskers, can you also remember in which show she came from?

Question 17

In which show do we see Brooke Shields play a stalker?

This American sweetheart has graced us with her presence in many a TV show and movie. She is not only known for her acting abilities, but also her gorgeous face as she started her long career as a child model. During her cameo on the show in question she plays a hysterical stalker obsessed with a fictional character she sees on TV. While scared of her and her stalker ways the boys of the show can't help but indulge her because of well come on...that face.

Question 18

In which show does a character dress a body pillow up as their boyfriend while he is away?

We've all been there, missing someone important to us. Their looks, smell, voice, all become hard to live without after a while. While we all cope in different ways; phone calls, post cards, what ever gets you through the day, our lady in question has a unique way of feeling close to her loved one while he is away. She takes to dressing up a large body pillow in his clothes, and props it up for her to sit and enjoy meals and bed time with.

Question 19

In which show do we see the characters attend " Dick Clark's New Years Rockin' Eve?

After meeting and dating a professional dancer, one of this show's leading men gets invited to attend the filming of "Dick Clark's New Years Rockin' Eve". This annually televised event just happens to also be a childhood favorite for 2 of the show's other main characters. During the episode we see an excited group of friends arrive at the filming, and are blessed with the opportunity to watch a very special choreographed dance routine performed by our 2 childhood die-hard fans.

Question 20

In which show does a sister carry her brother's triplets?

This one goes down as one of the most unconventional TV pregnancies of all time. After finding out he and his wife cannot have babies on their own due to her being older, this character enlists the help of his sister. While she agrees to go through the In Vitro process and carry a baby for them, neither her nor her brother thought that triplets would be the end result. In which show do we watch this leading lady tote around her brother's "litter" of kids?

Question 21

In which show do we see a character get stung by a jellyfish?

A day at the beach sounds like paradise to most of us, but imagine a scenario in which you and your friends are at the beach ready for a good time when all of a sudden a sharp pain pierces through you. You realize the cause is a squishy little creature with electrifying tentacles. The only cure for your pain is...yikes..having one of your friends "relieve" themselves on your injury site. Can you remember which poor character gets put into this exact situation and the show they belong to?

Question 22

Which show does this secondary character belong to?

While his role is secondary at best, it is a vital one. Without this b-list character our gang of friends wouldn't make it to half of their adventures. By using him only on occasion the writers for the show in question ensure that every time we see him, or hear his famous name, we get super excited, and know something awesome is about to happen. Thinking back on both shows, can you pinpoint in which one you remember seeing him drive around the city?

Question 23

Which show famously showcases U2'S hit song "With Or Without you?"

We first hear this song in the 8th episode of the second season of this show. This classic rock ballad hits all the emotions as it plays during a rainy evening setting. While it may not be the song you'd want associated with you and your loved one, it certainly goes down as a defining sound to the ups and downs of this famous couple's on and off again relationship. Can you remember which show made you tear up to this Bono favorite?

Question 24

Which show does the cookie jar " R2 Sweet tooth" belong to?

While moving out of their long-time shared apartment, these friends spend an episode going through items and reminiscing on all the good times they had together. SO SAD! One of the items that get brought into question is their faithful robot-shaped cookie jar, which they so adorably named "R2 sweet tooth". Once they decide it's too difficult to move away from each other, they begin unpacking and resolve to never ever leave the apartment. Which show depicts this crazy episode?

Question 25

We see a leading man get an embarrassing butterfly tattoo in which show?

This is the stuff of nightmares. Going out for a few drinks with your friends, trying against all odds to have a good time after a recent break-up, only to wake up the next morning with a painful sensation on your lower back. The only thing more painful than the realization that you now have an embarrassing butterfly tattoo, is realizing you now need 10 sessions of laser removal therapy. If this show taught us anything it is to steer clear of tattoo shops when intoxicated.

Question 26

In which show do we witness a leading man lose a baby toe?

Medical emergencies are few and far between in most sitcoms, due to writers wanting to keep the general feelings light and funny. This specific scene however is light, funny, and downright emergent. While preparing a Thanksgiving feast and trying to flirt at the same time, one of our characters gets a little overwhelmed, and loses their grip on what turns out to be a rather sharp knife. The knife lands straight onto our leading man's foot, and due to his poorly crafted shoes, manages to slice the toe clean off.

Question 27

In which show does a leading lady get offered her dream job in Paris?

The final episodes of any beloved series are always the hardest to watch. During the final season of the show in question we are hit with countless emotional ups and downs. One of the larger heartbreaks of this season is watching one of our leading ladies get offered a dream job far away in Paris. While we are happy for our fictional pal we can't help but think "NO!" you have to stay here in New York and entertain us forever.

Question 28

In which show does a character hilariously lie about their ability to speak french?

While composing their resume this character decides to embellish the "special skills" portion a bit by adding in talents they have absolutely no idea about, including their ability to speak French. Once getting a callback for a job they quickly realize the employer is expecting a fully fluent French speaker for the job. He recruits a friend who DOES speak the language to help him learn in record time. Inevitably the lessons do not go as well as planned, and our character must use their own version of the language to get through the job interview.

Question 29

In which show do the characters successfully pull off a rain dance?

Controlling the weather is no easy feat. In this particular case we see a leading character try and create a rainstorm to keep his love interest away from another man during a planned camping trip. While this may seem overbearing and controlling, it is our leading man's last ditch effort to get the girl of his dreams. Say what you will about the desperate act, in the end he is successful and creates the storm of all storms preventing his love from attending the camping event.

Question 30

In which show do we see a leading man shave his head minutes before his wedding?

While both of these shows each have several unforgettable wedding episodes, the one in question takes the "wedding" cake. Nothing seems to be going right for this couple on their wedding day which is totally relatable, because whose wedding goes off flawlessly without any problems? NO ONE'S! However in the case of this groom the panic becomes all to real. In a desperate moment this character decides the best he can do for his hair is to shave it...moments before walking down the aisle.

Question 31

"You just got slapped" Which show does this song belong to?

"What is this feeling, that's put you in your place? A hot red burnin' on the side of your face. You feel the blood rush to your cheek tears start to fill your eyes, and your lips are trembling but you can't speak. You're trying, oh, you're trying not to cry. You just got slapped, across the face, my friend. You just got slapped. Yes, that really just happened. Everybody saw it, and everybody laughed and clapped. It was awesome, the way you just got slapped." Which show dies this tune belong to?

Question 32

"Smelly cat, smelly cat, what are the feeding you?" Which show do these lyrics belong to?

"Smelly Cat, Smelly Cat, what are they feeding you? Smelly Cat, Smelly Cat. It's not your fault. They won't take you to the vet. You're obviously not their favorite pet. Smelly Cat, Smelly Cat, it's not your fault. You may not be a bed of roses. You're no friend to those with noses. I'll miss you before we're done. Or the world will smell as one." Probably one of the most famous songs to ever come out of a sitcom, can you remember which?

Question 33

In which show does Britney Spears play a receptionist?

Both shows in question are chalk full of celebrity cameos. Both because it makes for interesting TV, but also because a lot of the time the celebrity participating is a huge fan of the show and wanted to be written on. How cool is that? This time around we see the queen herself, Miss Britney Spears, play a quirky, optimistic, receptionist, who falls head over heals for one of the leading men. Unfortunately the feelings are not reciprocated and we never get to see the relationship advance.

Question 34

Which show was originally named "Insomnia Cafe?"

Most television shows go through a trail period during their conception. This means characters get written in and out, actors get cast and cut, plot lines flourish and dissolve, all before anyone knows what the final product is going to look like. What a lot of people don't know is that a lot of TV show pilots start off as movie ideas. Needless to say these ideas need to be pruned until perfect before anyone gets to watch. Can you figure out which show was pitched with this alternate title?

Question 35

In which show do 2 main characters dream of opening a bar named "Puzzles"?

We all have dreams, ambitions, and goals. For these 2 characters their dreams are revealed in a drunken conversation where they both admit to wanting to open their own bar. While they maybe get a little too excited over the idea, I think we can all agree that it would be super cool to own a bar with our best friend! What would the name of yours be? For our 2 men in question there is only one possibility; Puzzles.

See Your Result
Questions Left
Current Score