Even True Fans Can't Get 100% On This Vampire Diaries Couples Quiz

Although The Vampire Diaries ended over a year ago, it's one of those series we really don't get tired of. The perfect combination of high school drama, relationships, thrill, horror and magic, this series had us all on the edge of our seats, desperately waiting for the next episode or season. An eight year run and one spin-off later, The Vampire Diaries came to a close, and yes, all of our hearts were forever broken. Thank goodness for the gift of Netflix and the internet's ability to make the fandom live on forever...because let's be honest, whether anyone was team Stefan or Damon, we've all nostalgically re-watched this show just to put ourselves through the same emotions.

And boy, was this show full of emotions. The writers gave us ALL the feels with the cutest couples, the most romantic boys, and about as many star-crossed lover story lines they could possibly think of. In fact, the romantic story lines are so elaborate and intertwined that it's kind of difficult to keep up with who dated who, when relationships started and ended, or what even happened in these relationships. One thing is sure, though - no character was left single for too long. Who thinks they can remember all of the couples, their moments and their history? This quiz is for real fans!

Question 1

Which Salvatore did Elena meet first?

Any 'The Vampire Diaries' fan knows this without a doubt: the biggest romantic story line in the show and the books is the love triangle between Elena and the two vampire brothers vying for her heart, Stefan and Damon. She dates both (spoiler alert), and the fandom's preference of Salvatore is highly contested. We gotta give it to them, though, both boys are wildly romantic, dashing, and irresistible... it's no wonder that Elena got caught up with both of them!

Question 2

Where did Elena and Stefan meet?

Ok, maybe you didn't remember that Damon is actually the Salvatore who met Elena first - she just didn't remember because he compelled her to forget. It was a tricky question, but a true fan remembers! It would be too easy to ask which Salvatore Elena dated first - everyone knows it was Stefan - but can you remember where they first met and spoke? This is the moment that marked the beginning of their long, adorable (and very tumultuous) love story!

Question 3

What's the first gift Stefan gives Elena?

Before Elena ever finds out that Stefan is a vampire, or even has time to notice something is fishy about him, the couple lives out the perfect high school romance. The cute, popular cheerleader (or ex cheerleader, rather) and the new, mysterious bad boy (who happens to be really good at football)... it's the perfect pair. Although Bonnie warns Elena that she feels weird about Stefan, he treats Elena like a true princess, even giving her a family heirloom as a gift.

Question 4

Who was Elena dating before Stefan?

Before meeting Stefan, Elena was devastated, alone, and lost. Having lost both of her parents in a car accident, her life was completely turned upside down from one day to the next. Of course, that meant that she was single for a little bit. But before all of that happened, Elena was dating a very cute someone who was probably more into her than she was into him. It was a very typical high school couple, but definitely wasn't built to last.

Question 5

Who does Caroline first date in the series?

By the end of the series, Caroline has definitely dated quite a few Mystic Falls men. She's fiesty, a born leader, sometimes puts her foot in her mouth, but overall, is ambitious, kind, and a loyal friend. Honestly, she's a handful, but a real catch! That's probably why so many boys fall in love with her - although so many of her relationships take a turn for the worst, are really difficult, or just end horribly. Poor Caroline, she deserved better!

Question 6

Which Salvatore boyfriend did Katherine typically compel?

Clearly, in the Vampire Diaries, history really does repeat itself. The Salvatore brothers' journey as vampires all started when they met Katherine (aka Katerina Petrova) and fell in love with her. She also is the one who turned them into vampires...isn't she just the sweetest? Though both boys were in love with Katherine, one of them was less willing to bend to her demanding wishes, so she regularly compelled him. The other was so consumed with love that he did anything she asked willingly.

Question 7

Which lover did Katherine claim she truly loved?

Katherine was an evil character, but she still had feelings. At least, she claimed to have them. She played with Damon and Stefan Salvatore for years, changed their lives beyond repair by turning them into vampires, and broke both of their hearts. Always selfish, always looking out for her own survival and well being above all, but still capable of love. At least, we think so. Katherine has had quite a few lovers, but there's only one that she claims to have really loved.

Question 8

Who do Jeremy and Tyler fight over?

We love us some drama, and you know that the Vampire Diaries always delivers on drama. Elena isn't the only girl that two guys are after, because Tyler Lockwood and Jeremy, Elena's younger brother, are into the same girl during season one. Tyler notoriously treats her like trash, while Jeremy claims to really care about her and have her best interests at heart. Guess things get pretty weird and intense when you live in a small town like Mystic Falls!

Question 9

Which of Jeremy's girlfriends was a vampire when they met?

Jeremy has had his fair share of girlfriends in the show, but his love stories never end very well. He keeps getting hurt time after time and getting into relationships that are doomed from the start. Poor kid got swept up in a bunch of vampire drama that really had nothing to do with him - and because of it, he ended up dating a few super natural girls (literally). No matter how much Elena tried to protect him, Jeremy still ended up with a vampire.

Question 10

Who kept on being haunted by an ex-girlfriend's ghost while he dated someone else?

You know you're watching the Vampire Diaries when a boy starts to be haunted by the ghost of his ex-girlfriend. Meanwhile, there are other vampires lurking around town with a nasty revenge plan and a thirst to kill. It's like Ghosts of Girlfriends Past, but with a supernatural, bloody twist. It's not safe for anyone in Mystic Falls - not even the unsuspecting or innocent humans. And boy, did this awkward situation put a strain on this guy's love life!

Question 11

Where did Damon and Elena meet?

Damon and Elena have a tumultuous relationship to say the very least. Full of ups and downs, a little bit of disloyalty (Damon did go after his brother's girl, after all), but epic nonetheless. They were challenged time after time by their friends, who thought the match was bad news, by external forces trying to tear them apart, or even by their turned off humanity switches and magical spells. Whether you're team Damon or Stefan, it does seem like they were meant to be.

Question 12

Which boyfriend did vampire Caroline accidentally bite?

Oof, talk about a steamy make out sesh. Imagine you're just minding your own business with your significant other in the woods, and they decide to bite a chunk out of your carotid artery. Sounds like a bit of a red flag, or even a deal breaker, but somehow this relationship persisted. Poor Caroline couldn't control her baby vampire urges, being totally new to the overwhelming desire to eat her own friends. Though this couple was cute, it was also a bit of a stressful mess. Yikes.

Question 13

Which boys did Caroline have overlapping relationships with?

Okay, let's be clear here: Caroline did not cheat on anyone. Although she is a vampire, she's not a heartless monster! With that being said, there was a weird point in Caroline's story line where she was being pursued by two different guys - a kind of ex boyfriend, and a future one. Needless to say, because of the cuteness of the Mystic Falls boys, she was very conflicted. So were we, Caroline, so were we. We don't blame you.

Question 14

How did Tyler and Caroline start their relationship?

Tyroline or Caroler, whichever you want, is undeniably one of the cutest Vampire Diaries couples ever. Although their couple name doesn't have that much of a ring to it, their vampire-werewolf dynamic was the perfect combination of steamy and adorable. The two fought for each other like none other, making them what we now call "couple goals". Although no one really saw it coming at first, it made so much sense when it happened...and their origin story makes their relationship that much better!

Question 15

Which of these boys was Bonnie's last boyfriend?

Kind of like Jeremy, Bonnie's relationships were never easy. Whenever something had to give, it was usually Bonnie. She lost family, friends, and lovers, time after time, for the sake of the greater good. Not only is she a selfless friend, she's a loyal partner - something that a few lucky guys had the chance to experience. Her last relationship of the series was probably the most unlikely, but also the best. She deserved nothing less for her final love story.

Question 16

Who did aunt Jenna last date?

Man, things really sucked for Elena and Jeremy. As if it wasn't bad enough that they had already lost both of their parents in a car accident, they lost their guardian, their aunt Jenna, literally in the beginning of the show. Talk about a crappy family life. We all miss Jenna - she was so relatable, fun, and was really trying her best to raise Elena and Jeremy. At least she managed to have a little bit of fun and love in her life before passing.

Question 17

Which Original got involved with a teenager?

The Vampire Diaries was also the beginning of the Originals. The oldest, most powerful vampires alive pay a visit to Mystic Falls during the series, completely taking over the town. Basically impossible to kill and capable of compelling even vampires, the Originals were a dangerous enemy to have in town. One particular member of the family joined the high school and started seeing one of Mystic Falls' very own high school students. Creepy, given that they're all, like, 1000 years old.

Question 18

What ended Elena and Stefan's relationship?

Ugh, we know. It's a painful memory for us, too. To be completely honest, although many people wanted Damon and Elena to happen, no one needed to see Stefan's heart broken. Stelena had a rocky road, like most relationships do, but they seemed so right for each other, which is why the break up sucked so much. They had a few temporary break ups, but there was one that really ended their relationship for good and forever changed the show.

Question 19

Who did Caroline not date?

Hey, we're not shaming our girl Caroline in the slightest, but dang, that girl had a lot of relationships. It's kind of hard to keep up with who she did and didn't date, because it seems like everyone was after her. What can we say, we love a smart, positive, and beautiful girl like Caroline, and clearly, so did the Mystic Falls boys! The Vampire Diaries writers really took liberties with her love life. But let's not get ahead of ourselves; she didn't date absolutely everyone!

Question 20

Who was Alaric's first wife?

Jeremy Gilbert isn't the only one with a troubled love life...Alaric Saltzman was pretty unlucky, too! Our favorite vampire hunter disguised as an inoffensive history teacher once had a wife that he loved more than anything else...a wife who did him real dirty. She's also the reason why he got into vampire hunting in the first place, so I guess we have her to thank for seeing his beautiful face on our screens and for becoming Elena's new guardian figure.

Question 21

Why did Isobel leave Alaric?

This is probably the entire fandom's least favorite relationship. No one wants to see a kind, loving, loyal and handsome man be played and disrespected by his selfish wife. Even though he did everything he could to keep Isobel happy, he apparently wasn't enough and she ended things. What more could we expect from the woman who gave birth to and abandoned Elena, only to come back into her life unapologetically? Seriously, the only thing that sucked more than Isobel was the fact that she had to hurt so many people along the way.

Question 22

What ended Jo and Alaric's relationship?

Although being with Jo was probably Alaric's best and happiest relationship in the show, the writers decided that apparently, he didn't deserve to be happy! Anyone else a little angry? Cause we are. Why can't a stand up, respectful, handsome guy like Alaric just catch a break? Much like his relationships with Isobel, his first wife, and Jenna, Elena's aunt, Alaric's relationship with Jo was far from eternal. There's always something around the corner in Mystic Falls to ruin a perfectly good relationship!

Question 23

What are the names of Alaric and Jo's twins?

This was possibly the saddest story line in the Vampire Diaries ever..and that's saying something. With all the deaths, break ups, and turmoil, it's safe to say this show was never completely happy...but Alaric and Jo's romance made this show really dark. Jo and Alaric barely had time to get married before Jo died (thanks a lot, Kai). As if that wasn't sad enough, she was literally pregnant with twins, who inexplicably survive after being magically transferred to Caroline's stomach. Yeah, no one said it made sense.

Question 24

What gift did Klaus not give Caroline?

Okay, okay, these two technically didn't date, but it's safe to say that Klaus had a huge thing for Caroline. As tough and mean he was on the outside, our favorite Original vampire still had a soft spot and a heart. Like most of Caroline's suitors, he fell for her outspoken honesty, her loyalty and fiesty attitude. Klaus chased after Caroline even though she was with Tyler for the longest time, trying to woo her with kind words and gifts.

Question 25

Where did Caroline and Klaus hook up?

As much as Caroline tried to deny Klaus, push him away, and ignore the very obvious sexual tension and chemistry between them, Klaroline did end up happening...kind of. No, Caroline did not cheat on Tyler, but you can bet that he didn't take it well when he found out she had hooked up with the man who had previously treated him like slave. But boy, was the fandom happy about this. It was so overdue, and the scene is forever burned in our minds.

Question 26

Who does Caroline marry?

It's just so easy to use Caroline's relationships because of how many she has in the show. With that being said, there's only one man Caroline marries and wants to spend her life with...and it would have never happened without a little bit of character development - on both sides. Caroline's beautiful wedding was as short lived as her marriage, because, you know, no one in this show can be happy forever. Unless, maybe, you're Damon and Elena. Then you get a happy ending.

Question 27

What was special about Mary Louise and Nora?

Ugh, another underrated couple that didn't really get a happy ending. The Vampire Diaries definitely didn't give us enough LGBTQ representation, but Mary Louise and Nora were a start. Although they were kind of evil and definitely made our protagonists' lives harder, they were so cute with each other, and so committed. They also didn't stay evil forever, and ended up dying a sad but romantic death together. Guess it's only fair, given that they had been together for so long.

Question 28

Who was Stefan with before marrying Caroline?

It was about time that Stefan break away from being obsessed with Katherine and Elena, cause that was getting old. Plus, he deserved a happy love story after being screwed over by his brother and ex-girlfriend. We all know that Stefan's last relationship was Caroline (after A LOT of build up and time) - but this adorable Salvatore did have another relationship before settling down with Caroline. And let's be honest, we all knew this one wouldn't stand a chance.

Question 29

What was the first doppelganger couple?

It didn't take us very long to find out that Elena was a doppelganger spawned from a whole line of doppelgangers...meaning that her own descendants would eventually yield another doppelganger identical to her. The story goes back a while, but basically, there is a male doppelganger and a female doppelganger line, and every once in a while, doppelgangers come back around and are destined to end up with each other. And all of this started with the first couple's eternal love for each other.

Question 30

Who does Elena end up with?

This is like, the most important Vampire Diaries relationship question to be asking. The series began with a tense love triangle, and so it's only fair that it be resolved at the end of the series. It's the question we all wanted the answer to from the very beginning - who is end game? Is it Stelena, or Delena? Regardless of what you wanted to see happen, every real The Vampire Diaries fan knows which couple survived the test of time.

See Your Result
Questions Left
Current Score