Play One Tree Hill Would You Rather To See Which Scott Brother Would Choose You!

Let's face it, you can't really go wrong either way with the Scott brothers.

One Tree Hill is the story of these two brothers, Nathan and Lucas, and how growing up in a small town where everyone knows your family secrets can be hard. Luckily, with age and maturity the two are able to form a bond that any brothers would be lucky to have.

There is no denying that they are very different, with Lucas being interested in art and literature and is a much more introverted character than his brother, Nathan. Nathan is popular, outgoing, and brave. Despite being very different, they tend to have a few women in common that they have both been romantically involved with. I mean, who can really blame them, it is a small town after all.  They do have basketball in common, as well as a dedication to the loved ones in their lives. Oh, and one other thing they have in common... they are both GORGEOUS!

Take this One Tree Hill - Would You Rather quiz to find out how you would fit into the group in Tree Hill. Also find out which Scott brother would choose you to be their girl!

Question 1

Would you rather spend a Friday night at a book store or at a party?

Deciding how to spend your down time together is important in relationships. On one hand, it is important to find activities you can both enjoy together. On the other hand, it is nice to have someone in your life that can open you up to new experiences.

Question 2

Where are you likely to be found at a pep rally?

School spirit at Tree Hill High is pretty important to both Scott brothers, whether they would want to admit it or not. This does not mean that a girl would have to be a cheerleader to catch the interest of a Scott boy.

Question 3

Would you rather shop at a music store or a makeup store?

Where you enjoy browsing while shopping is definitely a way to tell what a person is interested in. How would you rather spend a Saturday afternoon? Strolling through a mall looking at make up? Or popping into different music shops downtown?

Question 4

Would you rather be an unknown hero or a powerful villain?

Nathan and Lucas share the same last name because they share the same father. Unlucky for them, their father happens to be Dan Scott. All three of these Scott men show their capacity to be good guys. They also all show that they are not perfect people, with a definite potential for evil.

Question 5

Would you rather give up music or give up video games for a year?

How do you like to unwind? Imagine it is a Monday night and you just had a long day at school. Would you rather relax and listen to some tunes? Or would you rather immerse yourself in the virtual world of a video game?

Question 6

Would you rather always be the leader or never be the leader?

Some people are natural born leaders. Other people tend to shy away from leadership roles. This is not because they are not as competent as a leader, but often they do not want the responsibility of the fate of others.

Question 7

Would you rather have the approval of your family or your friends?

Ideally, you would never have to choose between these two options. There are many different outlooks on what makes someone family. This usually ranges anywhere between "blood is thicker than water", to "relatives are determined by blood but family is determined by loyalty".

Question 8

Would you rather never get angry or never get sad?

Emotions are a powerful thing. Some of the most powerful emotions are negative ones. No one enjoys being angry or sad, but both of these emotions are a natural part of life. However, if you had the opportunity, which one would you make disappear forever?

Question 9

Would you rather work hard or work smart?

Relationships tend to do better when both people involved have a similar level of ambition. Both Lucas and Nathan Scott are incredibly successful in their lives. One of the reasons is that they both put a lot of work into creating a life they want to lead.

Question 10

Would you rather spend the afternoon with Mouth or Tim?

Getting along with not just your significant other, but there friends as well, is important for a long lasting relationship. The Scott brothers have been lucky to have the people they date get along with their friends. Which of these members of the Tree Hill friend group would you want to get to know over some quality time?

Question 11

Would you rather participate in dare night or the boy toy auction?

Every once in a while the kids in Tree Hill need a little excitement to shake up the daily happenings of a small town. Some of the most fun events for them are the boy toy auction in season 1, and dare night from season 2.

Question 12

Would you rather listen to rock or rap music?

It is no way a rule that two people in a relationship should like the same music. But, sharing the same taste in music has its benefits. For example, not arguing about what to listen to in the car, what to listen to while you are doing chores, etc etc.

Question 13

Would you rather be asked out in public or in private?

Tree Hill is a small town, so it can be particularly difficult to keep secrets. This is especially true in regards to keeping relationships a secret. Would you love the grand gesture of being asked out in public? Or would you much rather a private and emotional moment just for the two of you?

Question 14

Would you rather coach a winning team or play on a losing one?

Basketball is a large part of the lives of both Nathan and Lucas. They both love to play, they love the sport, and they love inspiring those around them to succeed. Would you rather be in the back ground, getting little recognition or be a famous athlete on a losing team?

Question 15

Would you rather be funny or smart?

Brooke Davis One Tree Hill

Ideally, you would not have to choose between either of these personality characteristics. But, for the sake of the game, which personality trait would you rather have? The ability to make people laugh, or the ability to wow people with your intellect?

Question 16

Would you rather be valedictorian or prom queen?

The first four seasons of One Tree Hill follow the characters through high school. High school, as we learned in the season 4, episode 13, "Pictures of You", showed just how much cliques played a role at Tree Hill High.

Question 17

Would you rather have two close friends or many acquaintances?

How someone treats their friends is a good way to tell how they treat the people they care about, which can show you how you can expect to be treated in a relationship. Some people prefer to have a few close friends, others prefer to have a lot of friends even if they are not as close.

Question 18

Would you rather participate in a fashion show or a concert?

Tree Hill is a place where dreams come true. Almost every member of the group reaches for the stars and obtains their dream job. Nathan is a professional basketball player, Lucas is a novelist, Peyton has red bedroom records, Haley is a teacher and an artist, and Brooke runs her own fashion line.

Question 19

Would you rather have hair that was always straight or always curly?

The ladies of One Tree Hill go through many different hair styles over the years. Who could forget the time Anna asked is Lucas preferred straight or curly hair and Peyton and Brooke stood beside her, obviously representing the two choices before she decided on "half and half".

Question 20

Would you rather be stranded on an island alone or with someone you dislike?

Different people handle difficult situations very differently. Would you rather be left up to your own devices, all alone? Or, would you rather have the company of another person; even if it is someone you do not generally like?

Question 21

Would you rather work at Tric or Karen's Cafe?

Both of these businesses are started out by Karen, the single mother with a knack for business. They are two staples in the world of Tree Hill, both of which hold important memories. Either way, you have Karen as a great boss, but where would you rather work?

Question 22

Would you rather fight psycho Derek or crazy Carrie?

One Tree Hill has featured more than its fair share of villains over the course of the show. Almost every main character experienced a run in with someone less than sane at one point or another. Which of these two would you rather face off against?

Question 23

Would you rather date Chris Keller or Jake?

Hypothetically, if you could not date either of the Scott brothers (don't worry - its only hypothetical), would you rather date Chris Keller or Jake? Both of these men are incredibly handsome and charming, but they are not without faults of their own.

Question 24

Would you rather be friends with Rachel or Nicki?

These two characters show up in Tree Hill and cause problems for our beloved main cast. Nicki is the mother of Jake's baby Jenny, and Rachel continuously tries to break up some of the best Tree Hill couples. Both of these girls also have positive qualities that fool our cast at one time or another.

Question 25

Would you rather only be able to give good advice, or only be able to take good advice?

Communication is key in a relationship, which is why being able to turn to your partner in a time of need is so important. Would you want to only be able to receive good advice, so that no one can steer you in the wrong direction? Or, would you rather all the advice you give to people be good and helpful?

See Your Result
Questions Left