Pick Your AHS Faves To Find Out What Kind Of American Horror Story You Would Star In

American Horror Story has everything an anthology series needs to be successful - a strong creative force (Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk), talented actors, intricate characters, interconnected stories, and of course, a good dose of scary! So far they've taken us into a haunted house with a gruesome backstory, an asylum for the criminally insane, a witches coven, a freak show, a hotel, a spooky isolated home with a dark history, and most recently, inside of a powerful cult. The show has been renewed for both an eighth and a ninth cycle so we know that we have at least two more seasons of AHS to enjoy.

Have you ever dreamed of creating your own American Horror Story season? What would your storyline be? Who would you choose to play the leading roles and what spooky or supernatural elements would you throw into the mix? Would you include a few real-life crime stories in your plot and what location would you choose? We've imagined six possible themes and stories for fantasy versions of AHS, all you have to do is tell us what you've enjoyed the most about the show and we'll tell you which one we think you would like best. Are you ready? Let's go.

Question 1

Who was your favorite mother figure in AHS?

Have you picked up one of the common themes in American Horror Story surrounding mothers? Well, often the characters have dysfunctional relationships with their mothers; just think about Tate Langdon, Dandy Mott, and Dr. Thredson. But there are decent mother figures scattered in between too. Who was your favorite mother figure in AHS?

Question 2

Which Sarah Paulson character did you like best?

Sarah Paulson is without a doubt the leading lady of American Horror Story. She's appeared in every single season of the show, often in a leading role. She's one of only eight cast members to ever play the same character in different seasons and the only one to ever do it more than once. Which of these Sarah Paulson characters did you enjoy the most?

Question 3

Which season had the best soundtrack?

You can't have a creepy story without the right kind of music to go along with it. The creators choose every song carefully and it always shows in the finished product. You might struggle to choose a fav season (they're all so good) but surely you know which season's soundtrack you enjoyed the most?

Question 4

Which supernatural element was the most entertaining?

The latest season of AHS (Cult) is unique because it is the very season of the series not to feature any kind of supernatural elements. What do you think about this? Do you feel like it's wrong? Do you think that supernatural features are the cornerstone of the show? Which of these elements did you personally find the most entertaining?

Question 5

Which Evan Peters character did you like best?

If Sarah Paulson is the show's leading lady then Evan Peters must surely be the male lead of the AHS. Evan, like Sarah, has appeared in every season of the show, usually in a main role. He's played a host of interesting characters but which of these did you like the most?

Question 6

Who do you think the scariest AHS doctor was?

Doctors are supposed to be caring individuals right? They are meant to be compassionate to the needs of the sick, and have their best interests at heart. Well, that's not the way it works in AHS. The show is packed with evil doctors who either mislead their patients or flat out mistreat them. Who was the scariest doctor for you?

Question 7

What color scheme would you use for your fantasy AHS season?

For the latest season of AHS, the creators chose a color scheme of blue with orange/yellow. If you watch carefully you see these colors pop up all the time, from lamps to the color of the characters hair. If you had to choose a color scheme for your fantasy AHS what would it be?

Question 8

What was your fav AHS location?

The show is called American Horror Story so accordingly, all the locations are in the USA. Throughout the seasons the characters have appeared in several locations although there are a few that have been repeated, which helps tie the seasons together. What would you say your fav AHS location was so far?

Question 9

Which Jessica Lange character did you like best?

When Jessica Lange announced that Freak Show would be her final season with the series fans were devastated. But Jessica felt that it was time to move on and we have to accept that. She initially only signed on for one season and ended up doing four, often playing the leading role. Which Jessica Lange character did you like best?

Question 10

Which horror movie legend would you like to see in AHS?

American Horror Story often borrows elements from well-known horror movies to make it even more creepy. Now we're designing your dream AHS season so we need you to choose which of these horror movie legends you'd like to include in the show? Would you like to see Tim Curry (from the original It movie) or one of the others?

Question 11

What time period would you choose for your fantasy AHS season?

Even though a season might be set in a certain time period, we often see backstories taking place in the past. Do you prefer the seasons set in modern times or do you think stories like Asylum and Freak Show were more interesting? What time period would you choose for your fantasy AHS season?

Question 12

Which urban legend would you like to see in AHS?

Urban legends are a strong theme in AHS; sometimes they are fictional - like the legend of the Piggy Man or the serial killer Bloody Face while other times they are rooted in recorded history, like Edward Mordrake. Urban legends are creepy all on their own but which one would you like to include in your dream AHS season?

Question 13

Which season did you find the most disappointing?

Every American Horror Story fan has their favorite season. According to the stats for the show, the two most popular seasons so far have been Coven and Freak Show. But likewise, most of us have a season that we didn't really enjoy that much. Which one was it for you?

Question 14

Who was your favorite vampire?

In AHS Hotel the lead character, Elizabeth AKA The Countess (played by Lady Gaga) has an "affliction". The side effects of this condition include the need to consume blood, and everlasting life. She was a vampire but she wasn't alone. Who was your favorite vampire at the Hotel Cortez?

Question 15

Which Kathy Bates character did you like best?

Kathy Bates is an incredibly versatile actress best known for her Oscar-winning performance in Stephen King's Misery. She joined the series for AHS: Coven where she played the evil Madame Delphine LaLaurie and had a main role in Freak Show, Hotel, and Roanoke. Which of her characters did you enjoy the most?

Question 16

Who was your favorite guest star?

American Horror Story has a cast of actors who take on different roles in each season but there are always fresh faces and guest stars to keep things interesting. It's hard to keep up with all the guest stars but if you had to choose a fav out of these four, who would it be?

Question 17

Which actress would you choose to play the lead in the next season?

One of the choices you'll need to make for your fantasy season of American Horror Story is which actress will play the lead role. We've lined up four potential leading ladies but now it's up to you to decide who you want it to be. Which actress would you choose to play the lead in the next season?

Question 18

Which actor would you choose for the lead role in the next season?

Now that you've chosen your leading lady it's time to pick out an AHS actor who will take the lead male role in your fantasy season. Do you think Evan Peters is the safest choice or do you think one of these other actors deserves more time in the spotlight? Who will it be?

Question 19

Which Lily Rabe character did you enjoy the most?

Lily Rabe, like Sarah Paulson, has appeared in every season of American Horror Story so far and it's rumored that she will return in a small role for AHS: Cult. She's played all kinds of characters, from a witch to a serial killer but which of her roles did you most enjoy?

Question 20

Who was your favorite monster?

Another essential element to any good horror story is a monster of some kind. Sometimes the monsters in American Horror Story look like regular people, while others are just terrifying to look at. If you had to choose one of these monsters, which would you say is the scariest?

Question 21

Which conspiracy theory would you like to see included in your fantasy AHS season?

American Horror Story often borrows elements of true crime for its storylines such as the reference to the (still unsolved) Black Dahlia murder case (Murder House) and the character based on H.H Holmes (Hotel). But what about conspiracies; do you believe they could be blended into the AHS universe?

Question 22

Which of these villains was your favorite?

American Horror Story has brought us some of the scariest villains to ever grace the small screen. They are not afraid to take things to the next level and seem to know what truly frightens us. There have been many villains over the years but which did you like best?

Question 23

Which Coven character would you love to see again?

Coven, the shows third cycle, remains one of the most popular seasons of AHS and for a good reason. This was the first time the show starred both Kathy Bates and Jessica Lange, which proved to be an incredible combination. Which Coven character would you love to see again?

Question 24

Which Denis O'Hare character did you enjoy the most?

Denis O'Hare is also a regular AHS cast member but his performances are often (unfairly) overlooked. He's appeared in every season of the show with the exception of Asylum however it's still unclear whether or not he'll have a role in the latest season, Cult. Which Denis O'Hare character did you enjoy the most?

Question 25

Which of these locations would you choose for your fantasy AHS season?

We're pretty sure that it doesn't make a difference which location the creators use for the next season of American Horror Story because it will still be amazing. But we're trying to find out what your dream season would look like so tell us - which of these locations would you prefer?

Question 26

Who was your fav young witch in Coven?

Miss Robichaux's Academy was a place for exceptional young ladies. Really exceptional in this case seeing as how they were all witches with incredible powers. Nan could hear people's thoughts, Zoe could kill with a touch and Queenie was like a human voodoo doll. Which young witch did you like best?

Question 27

Which of these celebs would you choose for a cameo in your dream season?

You've chosen the theme, location, and the main players for your fantasy season of American Horror Story but it's not over just yet. Now you need to get a few famous faces to make cameo appearances. We've lined up four who we think would be able to cut it, who will you choose?

Question 28

Which guest director would you choose?

Now when it comes to choosing a guest director for that crucial episode (that includes a major plot twist) you've got to think carefully. You need someone who is experienced but also willing to keep to the style that fans are accustomed to. Which of these directors would you choose?

Question 29

Which true crime story would you like to see included in AHS?

Most of the time, reality truly is stranger than fiction. Sure writers can dream up all kinds of crazy scenarios but often they pale in comparison to real-life events. If you had to choose one of these true crime stories to feature in your fantasy version of AHS, which one would it be?

Question 30

Which Freak Show character would you love to see again?

Let's imagine for a moment that all the performers from season 4's Freak Show survived (of course we know some of them didn't). Besides from Twisty (who has already returned for AHS: Cult), which other character would you love to see again, even just for a short cameo?

Question 31

What do you think the connection between all the seasons is?

While we all know that AHS seasons are connected through characters and locations some fans believe that there is a common theme that will only be revealed when the show finally ends. Are you one of these fans or do you think it's too far-fetched? Which of these do you think it's likely to be?

Question 32

Which Francis Conroy character did you enjoy the most?

Francis Conroy joined American Horror Story in the very first season of the show and has appeared in every season since with the exception of Hotel. She's a regular cast member, but would you choose her for your fantasy AHS season? Which of her characters have you enjoyed the most?

Question 33

Which musician would you choose for a cameo role?

Now we know that not all musicians can act but after seeing Lady Gaga in Hotel you might want to include another musical face in your fantasy line-up. Maybe they could even perform a song? Which performer would you love to see take on a cameo role in American Horror Story?

Question 34

Which Angela Bassett character was your favorite?

Angela Bassett joined the AHS family in Coven where she played the voodoo queen Marie Laveau and since then she's appeared in every season. She's been a three-breasted woman, a vampire, an actress, and even directed an episode of Roanoke. Which Angela Bassett character was your favorite?

Question 35

How many seasons of AHS have you seen?

Was there a season of American Horror Story that you just couldn't get into no matter how hard you tried? Maybe you started watching a season and just didn't finish? Or are you the type of fan who has been every single episode? How many seasons of AHS have you seen?

See Your Result
Questions Left