Pick The Better NFL Player And We'll Guess Your Favorite Team

One of the best aspects of watching football is seeing the best in the league shine when the lights are brightest. While every player that makes it into the NFL can lay claim to being among the best in the world, the ones that truly excel and reach the top are the ones that the fans are going to remember until the end of time. This season, we are getting a chance to witness some amazing players that are going to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame one day, meaning that there are games that people would be unwise to miss. It is hard to see now, but when a legend exits the game, he leaves a massive void to fill by a new crop of talented players.

Going to an NFL game means that fans are going to be surrounded by others proudly sporting their favorite player's jersey, and many people can identify players based on their number alone. NFL fans love to debate everything pertaining to the game, especially which players they feel are at the top. Comparing players is a tradition in the league, and each fan has their own opinion on the matter.

Today, we are going to have participants choose the better player on each entry, and at the end, we will guess their favorite team!

1Which Player Is Better: Alshon Jeffery or Michael Crabtree?

Alshon Jeffery and Michael Crabtree are both wide receivers in the NFL that are more than likely out of their prime, but both are still worthwhile contributors to their teams. Jeffery is still in Philadelphia with the Eagles, while Crabtree is doing his thing with the Baltimore Ravens. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

2Which Player Is Better: Andy Dalton or Joe Flacco?

Andy Dalton has been called a relatively underwhelming quarterback, but there is no denying that the man has been a success during his time in Cincinnati. Flacco, meanwhile, has a Super Bowl victory from a few years ago under his belt. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

3Which Player Is Better: Anthony Barr or Bruce Irvin?

Anthony Barr has spent his entire NFL journey playing with the Minnesota Vikings, and his tremendous play is why the Vikings pack one of the best defenses around. Bruce Irvin just saw his exit from Oakland, and he will look to get on another roster soon. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

4Which Player Is Better: Antonio Brown or Julio Jones?

At the level that he is playing now, there is no doubt the Antonio Brown is going to find his way into the Hall of Fame as one of the best to ever compete in the NFL. Turns out, Julio Jones is making his case for Canton as well. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

5Which Player Is Better: Baker Mayfield or Josh Allen?

Baker Mayfield and Josh Allen are two of the five quarterbacks that were recently taken in the first round of the 2018 NFL Draft. Mayfield has been doing his thing in Cleveland, while Allen is the man of the future for the Bills. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

6Which Player Is Better: Tom Brady or Drew Brees?

For this entry, we wanted to highlight two NFL performers that are among the best to ever do it at their position. Fans are hoping that this season ends with these two legends competing against one another in the Super Bowl. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

7Which Player Is Better: Cam Newton or Kirk Cousins?

Cam Newton is still putting up stats and leading the charge in Carolina at a pace that few defenses can actually keep up with. Kirk Cousins headed for Minnesota before this season began, and the team seems poised for a run in the playoffs. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

8Which Player Is Better: Case Keenum or Derek Carr?

Both of these quarterbacks are starting for the bottom two teams in the AFC West. Keenum was responsible for Minnesota making noise last year, while Carr is two years removed from a season that saw him as a legitimate MVP candidate. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

9Which Player Is Better: Tarik Cohen or Jalen Richard?

Having a diverse array of players on the offensive side of the ball is key in putting up points, and the Bears and Raiders should consider themselves lucky to have these men on board. Cohen has better numbers, but Carr relies on Richard. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

10Which Player Is Better: Gareon Conley or Denzel Ward?

Both of these gentlemen played in the same secondary while attending Ohio State, and they were instrumental in the success the program had. Conley and Ward are both showing the world that they are impressive players, but Ward is the one with the more impressive numbers. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

11Which Player Is Better: Amari Cooper or Josh Doctson?

After getting his start with the Oakland Raiders, Amari Cooper was recently shipped out of Oakland to Dallas for a first-round pick, and he is looking to regain his Pro Bowl form in Texas. Josh Doctson has become a favorite target of quarterback Alex Smith in Washington. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

12Which Player Is Better: Kirk Cousins or Sam Bradford?

Kirk Cousins is the man currently under center in Minnesota, and the hefty contract he received means that he has enormous expectations. Sam Bradford is a former top pick that has hauled in over $100 million over the course of his time in the NFL. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

13Which Player Is Better: Dak Prescott or Alex Smith?

The Cowboys are going to be forced to evaluate Dak Prescott this season to make sure that he is the man they want as their franchise quarterback moving forward. Alex Smith, after playing in Kansas City, is the man under center for Washington. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

14Which Player Is Better: Sam Darnold or Josh Rosen?

Sam Darnold and Josh Rosen were both taken in the first round of the 2018 NFL Draft and, because they played for rival teams in college, these two are no doubt going to be linked for the rest of their time in the sport of football. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

15Which Player Is Better: David Johnson or Marshawn Lynch?

David Johnson has spent his entire 2018 campaign looking to regain his form from a few years ago when he was a legitimate MVP candidate. Marshawn Lynch, meanwhile, may be in his final year in the NFL out in Oakland. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

16Which Player Is Better: Drew Brees or Russell Wilson?

Drew Brees is continuing to put up incredible numbers at this point in his NFL jersey, and he will be looking to add one more Super Bowl victory later this year. Russell Wilson has long been a good quarterback, and he was one play away from multiple Super Bowl wins. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

17Which Player Is Better: Earl Thomas or Harrison Smith?

After going down earlier in the year, Earl Thomas may very well have played his last game in a Seahawks uniform. He will be looking for a huge deal later this year. Harrison Smith remains one of the best in the business up in Minnesota. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

18Which Player Is Better: Nick Foles or Teddy Bridgewater?

Nick Foles was sublime in the Super Bowl, but his start to the 2018 season left a lot to be desired from his squad. Bridgewater has bounced back in recent years after dealing with some health issues, and he will be desirable once this season is over. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

19Which Player Is Better: Leonard Fournette or Dalvin Cook?

Leonard Fournette and Dalvin Cook were both considered among the best prospects entering the 2017 NFL Draft, and each player has been able to flash some promise thus far. Fournette is down in Jacksonville, while Cook is up in Minnesota. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

20Which Player Is Better: Rob Gronkowski or Travis Kelce?

A great receiving tight end is a commodity that any NFL team would be lucky to have. They add a dynamic component to any offense, and it just so happens that these two men are arguably the best in the business. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

21Which Player Is Better: Chris Harris Jr. or Marcus Peters?

Chris Harris Jr. has been doing some amazing things since entering the NFL, and even after the departure of key pieces, he is still playing at a high level for the Broncos. Marcus Peters was shipped to L.A. before the season began. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

22Which Player Is Better: Johny Hekker or Michael Dickson?

NFL punters never truly get the recognition that they deserve, which is an absolute joke. Punters like the two men on this entry can completely change the game with their ability to pin the opposition deep in their own territory. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

23Which Player Is Better: DeAndre Hopkins or A.J. Green?

DeAndre Hopkins has had to catch passes from an alarming number of quarterbacks, and despite the carousel, he has been putting up impressive numbers his entire NFL journey. A.J. Green is a pillar of consistency, and he is making a case for Canton every game. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

24Which Player Is Better: Melvin Ingram or Justin Houston?

The AFC West has long been loaded with premium talent in pass rushers, and both of these two men are all the proof that fans will need. They can completely dominate a game when on the field, and their teams are lucky to have them. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

25Which Player Is Better: Jameis Winston or Ryan Fitzpatrick?

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers are in the precarious position of dealing with two men vying for playing time at the quarterback position. Fitzpatrick seems to do better, but neither of them is able to get their team wins as of late. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

26Which Player Is Better: Marvin Jones or Mike Evans?

In recent seasons, Marvin Jones has been able to establish himself as the primary target for quarterback Matthew Stafford in Detroit, and he is capable of torching defenses. Mike Evans has been a dominant force since entering the NFL a few seasons ago. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

27Which Player Is Better: Jason Kelce or Rodney Hudson?

NFL centers are responsible for being the leader on the offensive line, and these two men are among the best in the business. Philadelphia’s Kelce is the brother of tight end Travis Kelce, while Rodney Hudson is the man out in Oakland. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

28Which Player Is Better: George Kittle or Jared Cook?

While Rob Gronkowski and Travis Kelce are the two tight ends in the league that get the most acclaim, there are some other tight ends that deserve respect as well. Kittle and Cook are making names for themselves out in the Bay Area. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

29Which Player Is Better: Sean Lee or Kiko Alonso?

Whenever Sean Lee is on the field and leading his men, the Dallas Cowboys defense comes alive and plays at a level that keeps them in football games. Alonso, meanwhile, is out in Miami playing at an exceptional level for the Dolphins. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

30Which Player Is Better: LeSean McCoy or Todd Gurley?

McCoy and Gurley are both considered among the best at their respective position, though it is Gurley that has the luxury of playing for a great team in Los Angeles. For McCoy, he is currently playing football with a lowly Bills squad. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

31Which Player Is Better: Luke Kuechly or Vontaze Burfict?

Even though both of these men are talented, only one of them in known for being an upstanding man when the pads aren’t clacking. Kuechly is beloved by all, while Burfict has taken his share of heat from people due to his style of play. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

32Which Player Is Better: Khalil Mack or Von Miller?

In a trade that no one saw coming, the Oakland Raiders shipped off Khalil Mack to the Chicago Bears for a bounty of picks, and Mack has been as advertised for the Bears. Von Miller continues to be among the best in the business in Denver. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

33Which Player Is Better: Marcus Mariota or Eli Manning?

Marcus Mariota was instrumental in the Tennessee Titans reaching the playoffs last year, but the team has not been able to perform as expected this year. Eli Manning is getting close to the end of the road in New York. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

34Which Player Is Better: Matthew Stafford or Nathan Peterman?

Matthew Stafford has been able to put up stats at an alarming rate during his time in the NFL, and he has always been known for having exceptional arm talent. Peterman is also putting up numbers, though not in the categories his team is hoping for. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

35Which Player Is Better: Odell Beckham Jr. or Calvin Ridley?

Odell Beckham has been one of the most talented players in the league for some time, and he is known for making the impossible happen while he is on the field. Ridley may be a young player, but he has done great things in Atlanta. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

36Which Player Is Better: Patrick Peterson or Xavier Rhodes?

Talented players in the secondary can help a defensive line get to the quarterback by blanketing their receivers, and these men are still some of the best around. Peterson is doing his thing in Arizona, while Rhodes is on a stacked Vikings defense. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

37Which Player Is Better: Julius Peppers or Myles Garrett?

Even though these men are on opposite ends of their time in the league, both of them are still key components of their defenses. Peppers is a grizzled veteran that has long made a case for Canton, while Garrett is the man in Cleveland. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

38Which Player Is Better: Adrian Peterson or Saquon Barkley?

After looking like he was on his last leg and ready to retire, Adrian Peterson has been truly terrific in Washington so far this season. Barkley, meanwhile, was taken high in the NFL Draft, and he has been better than advertised in New York. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

39Which Player Is Better: Ryan Kerrigan or Bradley Chubb?

Ryan Kerrigan does not receive nearly as much coverage as some of the other players in the league, but that hasn’t stopped him from playing some exceptional football. Chubb was a high pick by the Broncos, and he has been turning things on lately. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

40Which Player Is Better: Aaron Rodgers or Dak Prescott?

No matter who is lining up next to him on the offensive side of the ball, Aaron Rodgers is still slinging the rock and playing like the best player in the entire league. Prescott has impressed in the past, and the Cowboys need him to perform well. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

41Which Player Is Better: Matt Ryan or Blake Bortles?

Matt Ryan and the Falcons are soaring this season, and Ryan has been playing some of the best football that he has ever played, even if Julio Jones isn’t catching touchdowns. Bortles is looking to lead the Jaguars back to the playoffs. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

42Which Player Is Better: Ndamukong Suh or Aaron Donald?

No one in the world thought that they would actually see a place and time when these two men were on the same team, but the Rams saw to it that they build a contender that could compete for a Super Bowl over the next few years. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

43Which Player Is Better: Terrelle Pryor or Kelvin Benjamin?

Terrelle Pryor got his start in the NFL as a quarterback for the Oakland Raiders several years ago, and he has spent the last few years playing as a wide receiver. After a falling out in Carolina, Kelvin Benjamin has been a contributor for the Bills. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

44Which Player Is Better: Adam Thielen or Davante Adams?

Adam Thielen and Davante Adams are both playing at a high level in the NFC North, and each has made life easier for their respective quarterbacks. Thielen has been breaking records, and Adams has been playing at a Pro Bowl level. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

45Which Player Is Better: Michael Thomas or Cole Beasley?

Michael Thomas has developed into a favorite for quarterback Drew Brees, which means that he is putting up amazing statistics this season. Beasley has been the primary target for Dak Prescott since the quarterback took over a few seasons ago. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

46Which Player Is Better: Todd Gurley or Alvin Kamara?

Todd Gurley is playing the best football of his life, which means that he could be in line for the NFL MVP once this season reaches its end. Kamara, meanwhile, has picked up where he left of last season for New Orleans. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

47Which Player Is Better: Justin Tucker or Daniel Carlson?

Justin Tucker has been the best kicker in the NFL for some time now, and he is as automatic as any kicker in history. Carlson was a phenom while playing with the Auburn Tigers, and he currently plays for the Raiders. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

48Which Player Is Better: Bobby Wagner or Thomas Davis?

Bobby Wagner is one of the few pieces left of the vaunted Seahawks defense from a few years ago. Even though he has less talent, he is still among the best in the world. Thomas Davis has long been playing some amazing football. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

49Which Player Is Better: Deshaun Watson or Jared Goff?

Deshaun Watson and Jared Goff got their journeys off to drastically different starts. Deshaun came out the gate and looked like an immediate All-Pro, while Goff had many people insinuating that he was going to be little more than a bust. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

advertising

50Which Player Is Better: Ezekiel Elliott or Mark Ingram?

Ezekiel Elliott has been a phenom since his playing days at Ohio State, and he has been among the best in the NFL ever since making his debut for the Cowboys. Mark Ingram had a slower start, but once everything started clicking, he completely took over. This choice will help us determine each participant’s favorite team!

See Your Result
Questions Left