Pick The Best NFL Quarterbacks And We'll Reveal Who's GM Material

Playing quarterback in the NFL is one of the most demanding things that an athlete could ever take part in. Not only does a quarterback need to have an exceptional level of athleticism, but they also need to have intelligence in spades to assess what is going on before each play even begins. The men that are able to rise to the top while playing this position are able to secure a massive salary and go down as legends. As it stands now, the best quarterbacks in the NFL are setting records and doing things that we as fans have never seen before, which has made for an exciting season.

While many of the best around in this day and age are aged veterans that have been in the trenches for a substantial amount of time, there are younger men that are showing the world that they are ready to take over and redefine the position for the next generation of players. With the group of professionals that we get to watch today, we as fans are incredibly spoiled and should count our blessings.

Today, we are going to pit quarterbacks against one another on each entry to see which participants would make good NFL GMs!

Question 1

Which Quarterback Is Better: Aaron Rodgers or Derek Carr?

Since coming into the NFL, Aaron Rodgers has been able to rise above the occasion and put up incredible numbers. Carr wasn’t as touted coming into the league, but he has been able to do some solid things in Oakland. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 2

Which Quarterback Is Better: A.J. McCarron or Teddy Bridgewater?

A.J. McCarron and Teddy Bridgewater are both young quarterbacks that are looking for opportunities to become starting quarterbacks in the league. They are both talented players, and they possess different sets of skills that help set them apart from the rest of the league. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 3

Which Quarterback Is Better: Alex Smith or Robert Griffin?

Alex Smith has been in the league for a substantial amount of time, and his accuracy on the field is largely why he has been able to sustain such a lengthy run in a tough league. Robert Griffin came into the NFL with a ton of promise, and he remains a solid player. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 4

Which Quarterback Is Better: Andrew Luck or Deshaun Watson?

Andrew Luck had huge expectations when he first came into the NFL, and when he has been healthy; he has been able to produce at a high level. Watson hasn’t been in the league long, but he has made an impact already. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 5

Which Quarterback Is Better: Andy Dalton or Baker Mayfield?

Andy Dalton may be the one that has been playing in the NFL for a longer amount of time, but the argument can be made that Baker Mayfield is the one that has already had a larger impact on the team that he plays for. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 6

Which Quarterback Is Better: Baker Mayfield or Josh Allen?

Both Baker Mayfield and Josh Allen are still young in their NFL journeys, and both men were drafted with the hopes that they would eventually develop into the best and brightest quarterbacks to lead the NFL in the future. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 7

Which Quarterback Is Better: Ben Roethlisberger or Russell Wilson?

These grizzled veterans are no strangers to finding massive amounts of success in the NFL, and both of them have been leading the charge for their teams longer than people realize. Roethlisberger and Wilson have both done things that others can only dream about. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 8

Which Quarterback Is Better: Blake Bortles or Jared Goff?

Blake Bortles and Jared Goff are both playing for teams that were expected to do some big things during the 2018 season. The Jaguars have floundered, while the Rams have shown the world that they have one of the most complete rosters around. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 9

Which Quarterback Is Better: Cam Newton or Eli Manning?

These men are at drastically different phases of their journeys, though both go out and compete every Sunday like it is the last time they ever will. Newton is the far more mobile quarterback, but Eli has had more success. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 10

Which Quarterback Is Better: Carson Wentz or Drew Brees?

Carson Wentz is being hailed as the future of the league thanks to what he has done in his young run, and people expect him to continue to do great things. Drew Brees is still playing at a level that is reserved for only the best. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 11

Which Quarterback Is Better: Case Keenum or Kirk Cousins?

After having a stellar college run, Case Keenum has been looking to make waves in the NFL for several years now. Kirk Cousins was slated to be a backup player, but his talent was too much to ignore earlier in his journey. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 12

Which Quarterback Is Better: Dak Prescott or Marcus Mariota?

Both of these young quarterbacks are mobile players that can create opportunities by using their feet effectively. Prescott hasn’t been in the league as long as Mariota, though both of these men have been able to do some solid things. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 13

Which Quarterback Is Better: Derek Carr or Jameis Winston?

Derek Carr has been suiting up for the Raiders his entire time in the league, and he appears to be their best piece as they move forward in relocating to Las Vegas. Jameis Winston was supposed to be the man in Tampa, but there is some uncertainty there. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 14

Which Quarterback Is Better: Deshaun Watson or Philip Rivers?

These two men couldn’t be further apart in terms of where they are in their time in the league, but there is no denying that they have had a profound impact on their respective teams thanks to what they do on the field every Sunday. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 15

Which Quarterback Is Better: Drew Brees or Ryan Fitzpatrick?

Drew Brees is going to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame when he finally decides to hang up his cleats, and his production is still off the charts. Ryan Fitzpatrick has put up amazing numbers when he is making good decisions on the field. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 16

Which Quarterback Is Better: Eli Manning or Geno Smith?

Eli Manning and Geno Smith are two quarterbacks that many people have seen sling the football over the years, and each man was poised to do big things when they first made their way into the NFL all those years ago. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 17

Which Quarterback Is Better: Jameis Winston or Paxton Lynch?

Jameis Winston and Paxton Lynch are still in the first phase of their journey in the NFL, and Winston has been the quarterback that has had more opportunities to succeed thus far. Each man brings something unique to the field. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 18

Which Quarterback Is Better: Jared Goff or Lamar Jackson?

It is never easy to come into the NFL and make an immediate impression on the fans at home, and these men know a thing or two about that. Goff and Jackson both have had huge expectations placed on their shoulders. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 19

Which Quarterback Is Better: Jimmy Garoppolo or Nick Mullens?

Jimmy Garoppolo and Nick Mullens both suit up for the 49ers, and each man has gotten the opportunity to start games for the storied franchise. Each man has been able to flash their potential on the field during this season. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 20

Which Quarterback Is Better: Joe Flacco or Josh Rosen?

Joe Flacco and Josh Rosen are two men that have had the distinction of coming into the NFL with the intention of being the franchise cornerstone moving forward, and Flacco has been doing his thing for far longer than Josh Rosen. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 21

Which Quarterback Is Better: Josh Rosen or Sam Darnold?

The 2018 NFL Draft saw a number of men coming into the NFL to chase their dreams and seize the opportunity to become legends of the sport, and both of the men on this entry came into the NFL during this most recent draft. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 22

Which Quarterback Is Better: Marcus Mariota or Nick Foles?

Marcus Mariota and Nick Foles both have plenty of arm talent, and each man has been able to flash this talent during their time in the NFL. Mariota, however, is the one that is known for being a more mobile quarterback. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 23

Which Quarterback Is Better: Matthew Stafford or Matt Ryan?

Matthew Stafford and Matt Ryan came into the NFL with the promise of turning their teams around, and each man has been putting up amazing number during their time in the NFL. Each man is capable of taking over a game. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 24

Which Quarterback Is Better: Mitch Trubisky or Matt Schaub?

Both of these men have had their opportunity to lead a franchise moving forward, though they are now at vastly different phases of their NFL journey. Trubisky came into the NFL more recently than Schaub, though Schaub has more experience. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 25

Which Quarterback Is Better: Nathan Peterman or Matt Barkley?

Nathan Peterman and Matt Barkley have both seen their ups and downs during their time in the NFL. These men play perhaps the hardest position in the league, and they have taken their lumps courtesy of opposing defenses sending their best pass rushers. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 26

Which Quarterback Is Better: Patrick Mahomes or Sam Bradford?

Patrick Mahomes and Sam Bradford are at different points of their NFL journey, and each man has been able to wow fans with their play on the field. They have both had games wherein they put up some massive numbers. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 27

Which Quarterback Is Better: Philip Rivers or Eli Manning?

These two quarterbacks have spent their entire runs being linked to one another, and there is belief that both of them will be enshrined in the Hall of Fame when each of them finally decides to hang up their cleats. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 28

Which Quarterback Is Better: Russell Wilson or Mike Glennon?

One of the most interesting things about the quarterback position is that men of different skill sets are able to make an impact on the league, and there is no better example than these men here. They could not be any more different from one another. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 29

Which Quarterback Is Better: Ryan Fitzpatrick or Sam Darnold?

Both of these men have had the pleasure of attending fantastic academic schools in their life, and each of them had the athletic prowess and work ethic to make their way into the NFL to play with the elite players in the world. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 30

Which Quarterback Is Better: Ryan Tannehill or Brock Osweiler?

Ryan Tannehill and Brock Osweiler each came into the NFL looking to find a starting job and restore a franchise to greatness, and each has been given the opportunity to do so. Both men currently play for the same team. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 31

Which Quarterback Is Better: Sam Bradford or Teddy Bridgewater?

There was a brief point in time when these two quarterbacks were part of the same NFL franchise, and each of them wanted nothing more than to see their team rise to the top and make their way to the Super Bowl. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 32

Which Quarterback Is Better: Sam Darnold or Patrick Mahomes?

Sam Darnold and Patrick Mahomes are young quarterbacks that have the potential to do some incredible things in their journey. Mahomes may have inherited the better squad, but Darnold can be special should his team be built around him. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 33

Which Quarterback Is Better: Tom Brady or Jimmy Garoppolo?

When the sun finally sets on his journey and he leaves teams alone finally, Tom Brady may go down as the best to ever make it in the NFL. Garoppolo is the much younger man that is looking to establish his own legacy. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 34

Which Quarterback Is Better: Kirk Cousins or Aaron Rodgers?

Both Kirk Cousins and Aaron Rodgers have arm talent in spades, and each of these men is capable of torching defenses when they are playing at the top of their game. They are each hoping to make a Super Bowl run. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 35

Which Quarterback Is Better: Trevor Siemian or Case Keenum?

The Denver Broncos have been trying to figure out their starting quarterback situation ever since Peyton Manning retired following his victory in the Super Bowl, and both of these men have had an opportunity to seize the job moving forward. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 36

Which Quarterback Is Better: Blake Bortles or Matt Cassel?

Blake Bortles and Matt Cassel has both been given opportunities to become legit franchise quarterbacks in the NFL, and while each man has been able to flash potential, many people feel that they just need to find the right circumstances. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 37

Which Quarterback Is Better: Deshaun Watson or Lamar Jackson?

Being able to have a mobile quarterback play under center means that an offense will be able to keep defenses guessing thanks to having a massive playbook. Both of these men can make plays with their feet and their arms as well. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 38

Which Quarterback Is Better: Derek Carr or E.J. Manuel?

Derek Carr and E.J. Manuel have both dropped some impressive passes to their receivers during their time in the NFL, and at times, it has appeared as though both of these men could lead a squad to big things. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 39

Which Quarterback Is Better: Andrew Luck or Nathan Peterman?

Andrew Luck and Nathan Peterman came into the NFL with wildly different expectations, though this did not stop either of them from trying their best to rise above the rest and cement themselves as premiere players in the NFL landscape. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 40

Which Quarterback Is Better: Joe Flacco or Nick Foles?

One of the incredible things about these two men here is that both of them came into situations that allowed them to reach the top of the league. Their ascension to the top was something that people enjoyed seeing play out. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 41

Which Quarterback Is Better: Matt Ryan or Jared Goff?

The task of carrying a franchise into the future is something that will cause regular people to crack under pressure, but both Jared Goff and Matt Ryan have been able to bear this burden while making it look as easy as pie. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 42

Which Quarterback Is Better: Andy Dalton or E.J. Manuel?

Andy Dalton and E.J. Manuel are two men that have been given chances to be among the best in the game, and despite having an immense amount of pressure, each man had moments that saw them do some truly great things. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 43

Which Quarterback Is Better: Aaron Rodgers or Landry Jones?

Aaron Rodgers and Landry Jones have both had the privilege of playing football in the NFL, though it is Rodgers that has had far more success than Jones thanks to being the starting quarterback of one of the most famous franchises around. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 44

Which Quarterback Is Better: Matthew Stafford or Eli Manning?

Matthew Stafford and Eli Manning had the eyes of the world fixed on them as they made their way into the NFL, and each man has done some great things. Stafford is the younger man of the two, but Eli has had more success. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 45

Which Quarterback Is Better: Baker Mayfield or Tyrod Taylor?

The Cleveland Browns have long been dwelling near the bottom of the NFL, and they brought both of these men into the fold this season in an attempt to bring the franchise to heights they have not seen in decades. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 46

Which Quarterback Is Better: Cam Newton or Alex Smith?

Even though these quarterbacks may seem to be different from one another, both of them are able to excel at similar things. Newton and Smith can create plays with their feet, but Newton does have the much bigger arm. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 47

Which Quarterback Is Better: Ryan Fitzpatrick or A.J. McCarron?

Ryan Fitzpatrick and A.J. McCarron have both been looking for the right fit since entering the NFL, and each man has been on more than one NFL roster over the years. Fitzpatrick has been given more chances to start so far. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 48

Which Quarterback Is Better: Carson Wentz or Derek Carr?

Carson Wentz and Derek Carr went to much smaller colleges when compared to some of the other quarterbacks in the NFL, and each man was still able to stand out from the pack en route to being drafted into the NFL. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 49

Which Quarterback Is Better: Russell Wilson or Landry Jones?

Russell Wilson and Landry Jones are two quarterbacks that bring different things to the table in terms of what they are able to do while under center. Wilson continues to be one of the most underappreciated players in the league. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

Question 50

Which Quarterback Is Better: Marcus Mariota or Robert Griffin?

Marcus Mariota and Robert Griffin came into the league with the belief that they could be the model quarterbacks for the rest of the league moving forward. The success has been there at times, but neither has redefined the position. This decision will help us decide who is GM material! (Pro Football Reference)

See Your Result
Questions Left