Pick Your Favorite American Horror Story Characters And We'll Guess Your Biggest Fear

American Horror Story, at its core, is a horror story. All the elements of a great horror movie are cunningly woven into the storylines - everything from haunted houses, witches, mental hospitals, demon possessions, freak shows, haunted hotels, serial killers, cults, the list goes on and on. The creators took these horror themes and gave them an update, added colorful characters, a little romance, and splashes of gothic imagery and the result was the American Horror Story: the show that has kept us intrigued since 2011.

In the world of AHS, it seems that everything the characters fear always happens to them, and the creators of AHS seem to be able to tap into our darkest fears and bring them to life. This might explain why the show continues to gain fans and why it's been renewed for both an 8th and 9th season. The bad news is that the 8th season is still several months away so in the meantime you'll just have to occupy yourself with AHS quizzes instead!

Today we want to see if we can guess your biggest fear! All you need to do is choose your favorites from the AHS universe and we'll see if we can get it right.

Question 1

Who was your favorite witch in Coven?

Season three of American Horror Story drew us into the secret world of modern witches and Voodoo Queens. With incredible performances from actresses like Jessica Lange, Angela Bassett, Kathy Bates, and Sarah Paulson, this season was a fan favorite. Which wicked witch did you like best?

Question 2

Which of these seasons did you enjoy the most?

Each season of American Horror Story has something different to offer - that's what keeps it so exciting! Each season there is a new story, a different location, and a fresh set of characters for us to enjoy. Of these four seasons, which one have you enjoyed the most?

Question 3

Who was your fav Sarah Paulson character?

Sarah Paulson is the undisputed Queen of American Horror Story and almost always has a leading role. She's appeared in all seven seasons of the show, and it's been confirmed that she will return for season 8 in 2018. Of these four characters, which did you enjoy the most?

Question 4

Pick an AHS doctor:

Doctors are meant to be people you can trust, but you wouldn't want to trust your life to any of the doctors in American Horror Story. They might be more interested in maiming or murdering you than actually helping!

Question 5

Pick your favorite lead character from Murder House:

This was the season where it all started. In S1 of AHS, the ill-fated Harmon family moves into the infamous Murder House, a house trying to contain one too many secrets. Who was your favorite lead character in this season?

Question 6

Who was your favorite recurring character?

Even though each season of American Horror Story features a new cast of characters, there are cross-overs from time to time. Usually, the character will only appear for a few scenes during a single episode. Which recurring character is your fav?

Question 7

Choose the best Angela Bassett character:

Angela Basset joined AHS in the third season where she wowed fans with her performance as Voodoo Queen Marie Laveau. She is, after all, an Academy Award-nominated actress! She appeared in four of the seven seasons of the show so far but which performance was her best?

Question 8

Who was the best bad girl?

The world of American Horror Story is no place for wimpy, timid girls - if they want to survive they need to be as tough as nails, and maybe, just a little bit bad too. Who is your favorite AHS bad girl?

Question 9

What was your fav cameo?

You never know who is going to pop up in an episode or two of American Horror Story. The show is known for its amazing cameos and for attracting the cream of the crop when it comes to performers. Who was your fav cameo?

Question 10

Pick your favorite lead character from Asylum:

Briarcliff Manor offered us plenty of intriguing characters to love and to hate, and even ones that we loved to hate! Among the lead characters, which of these characters from Asylum did you like best? Who gave the best performance?

Question 11

Choose the best Evan Peters character:

Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters are the only two AHS cast members who have appeared in all seven season of the show. If Sarah Paulson is considered The Queen of AHS that must make Peters The King! Of these four Evan Peters characters which one was the best?

Question 12

Pick your favorite Freak Show performer:

The creators of American Horror Story pulled out all the stops when it came to their fourth season. They blew the fans away with their unique Freak Show concept and a cast of unforgettable individuals. Who was your favorite performer?

Question 13

Which member of the Harmon family did you like best?

Was Ben too much of a coward for you? Was Violet just an annoying angsty teenager? Was Vivien too saccharine and oblivious? Which member of the Harmon family from Murder House did you like the most? Maybe it was Hallie the little poohuahua!

Question 14

Choose the best AHS true crime reference:

AHS often uses true crime references and real-life killers in their storylines. One such example is James Patrick March from Hotel who was modeled on the infamous serial killer H.H Holmes who also used a hotel to hide his victims.

Question 15

Choose your best Lily Rabe character:

Lily Rabe is one of the main cast members of American Horror Story. She's appeared in every season of the show (although she played the same character in Asylum and Freak Show) with the exception of Cult. Which of her characters did you like best?

Question 16

Pick your favorite lead character from Hotel:

The Hotel Cortez was not the type of place you'd want to check into for a vacation. Unless you had an unnatural obsession with vampires or liked hunting ghosts this wasn't a place you wanted to find yourself. Which lead character from Hotel was the best?

Question 17

Pick your fav location:

The AHS universe has it all when it comes to creepy locations! From the haunted house in Murder House to the menacing madhouse in Asylum, each season of the show has new places to inspire our fear. Which of these did you like most?

Question 18

Which season had the best opening credits?

AHS Roanoke was quite different to what fans were used to in terms of the style. For starters, the theme was kept secret right up to premiere and for the first time ever, there were no opening credits. Do you feel the opening credits are integral to the show? Which season did it best?

Question 19

Evan Peters potrayed a number of cult leaders in S7. Which was the best?

After proving his range with a wide assortment of characters from season one through six, Evan Peters took on a whole new challenge for season seven, portraying not just one character but seven. This included several infamous cult leaders. Which one did Peters pull off best?

Question 20

Who was your fav Jessica Lange character?

Veteran actress Jessica Lange has won several awards for her performances including two Academy Awards, four Golden Globes, and two Emmys. She was a main cast member in AHS from season one through to season four. Which of her characters did you enjoy the most?

Question 21

Pick an AHS kid:

Although children are hardly ever among the leading characters in American Horror Story, there have been young characters in almost every season of the show, often in supporting roles. Of these four AHS kids, which one gave the best performance?

Question 22

Who was your fav Denis O' Hare character?

Denis O'Hare is the only member of the AHS cast to appear in five out of the seven seasons. He had roles in Murder House, Coven, Freak Show, Hotel, and Roanoke, and was absent from Asylum and Cult. Which of this characters was the best for you?

Question 23

Who was your fav guest at the Devil's Night Soiree?

In the AHS universe, ghosts can only move around freely on one night of the year; Devil's Night. That's why James March chooses this night to host his macabre Devil's Night Soiree, to which he invites a number of serial killer ghosts...

Question 24

Who was your fav Kathy Bates character?

Kathy Bates is an award-winning actress who portrays Madame Delphine LaLaurie in Coven, Ethel Darling in Freak Show, Iris in Hotel, and the hostile tribe leader "The Butcher" in Roanoke, along with Agnes Mary Winstead, the in-universe actress who portrayed The Butcher in "My Roanoke Nightmare".

Question 25

Who would you give the "Best Ghost" award to?

In the AHS universe, a ghost is only able to pass on to the next life, once they have overcome their issues on Earth. Ghosts on the show are often bound to the places they died at, and as you can imagine, this can make them angry.

See Your Result
Questions Left